asae & the center annual meeting: part one

Well, I'm back from Nashville, and I have to say that I had a REALLY GREAT time at the ASAE & The Center Annual Meeting.  The staff did a fantastic job.  It was obvious that a great deal of creativity went into the planning for the meeting, and all of their efforts paid off by elevating the energy and enthusiasm level throughout.  The buzz among the attendees was awesome...everyone I talked to had fun and learned a great deal.  Most importantly, no one walked away from the meeting with the impression that this was your typical cookie-cutter ASAE meeting.  The spirit of the merged organization was unleashed in Nashville. Now it must be sustained everyday, day after day.  I'll offer a few thoughts on that subject on another day.  Today, I want to focus on some reflections on Nashville.

Continue reading "asae & the center annual meeting: part one" »

My For Immediate Release Interview

On Friday, I was interviewed by Shel Holtz and Neville Hobson of the For Immediate Release podcast.  The interview is now available for download, and I hope you'll take some time to check it out.  (It is 55 minutes in length.)

For those of you who listen to my podcast, Associations Unorthodox, you know that I met Shel at the International Association of Business Communicators conference in DC in late June.  Shel introduced himself as "a big fan" of my podcast, which was a truly thrilling thing to hear, because until that point I wasn't sure whether anyone other than my friends were listening.  It was a very exciting moment for me, and I was even more excited by Shel's interview invitation.  I hope I didn't disappoint him and I hope you'll enjoy the conversation!  I look forward to your feedback and pushback...

More on why best practices don't cut it...

Dave Snowden, internationally-recognized expert on knowledge, storytelling and social complexity, has given us more ammunition in the fight against mediocrity by best practice.  Speaking on Wednesday at an IBM event in Singapore, Snowden offered the following succinct yet powerful observation:

No company who has ever succeeded to be the market leader has ever done it by following the best practices set by the dominant leader in that space.

As I've been typing these words, I've been running a list of market leaders through my mind:  Apple, Google, Starbucks, FedEx, 3M.  Snowden is clearly correct.  None of these leading companies achieved its position by duplicating the work of others.  Instead, these companies focused their energies on advancing original ideas and built their continuing commitment to innovation as a prerequisite for sustainable success.

In his Singapore talk, Snowden also argued that necessity is the driver of innovation.  When the environment in which the organization operates changes dramatically, the pressure that people feel to try new approaches increases as the old ways of working become harder to sustain.  Apparently, Snowden isn't familiar with the association community, however, because necessity is precisely where we stand right now in our need for innovation.  So far, however, the pressure doesn't seem to have caused enough pain and discomfort for a critical mass of association leaders to induce them to make innovation a genuine priority.  I'm not that thrilled with the idea of making innovation happen due, in part, to a sense of fear.  But at this point, I'll take what I can get!

In any event, the next time someone in your association suggests that you look for best practices, tell them to seek out original ideas instead.  The former is almost certainly the road to being average, while the latter is the surer pathway to long-term success and realizing your association's full potential..   

More on the decline of best practices

Here's another reason why I hate best practices.  The words are those of Johns Hopkins University president, William R. Brody, and they come from a speech he delivered at the end of April:

Risk aversion is eventually going to drive America into second-class status in our increasingly global economy. Guaranteed outcomes mean lowering our expectations. And lowered expectations lead to mediocrity and sub-par performance.

We need to ask ourselves: what's going on here? (Emphasis added throughout)

Our interest in best practices reflects our growing desire for guaranteed outcomes and a lack of tolerance for risk.  But best practices do not provide guaranteed or even reliable outcomes.  In fact, they rarely work out the way we have in mind when we copy them.  In the comments to my last posting on this subject, there were suggestions that best practices are useful for learning.  I can understand that view, but I would challenge it.  Best practices typically inhibit real learning by limiting the scope of possible inquiry, i.e., we focus our attention on what we know from the best practice and not on what we don't know, which is typically where things break down and where learning is most needed.  Yet we assume the best practice is comprehensive in its handling of the unforeseen because, after all, it's a best practice.  Unfortunately, that is virtually never the case, because best practices deal only with the very specific, context dependent problems their originating organizations are trying to solve at any given moment.  Most best practices don't produce either genuine insight or foresight until they've broken down or failed altogether.

Continue reading "More on the decline of best practices" »

The EMSAL debate continues

My friend Ben Martin of the Certified Association Executive blog has posted a response to my posting from late May regarding the EMSAL (executive master of science in association leadership) proposal.  You can read the comment I posted to his blog offering my take on his most recent points when you click through on the bold red "a response" link above.

I'm really glad that Ben has stayed in this conversation with me.  He's a great guy and very smart.  Thanks Ben!  I'm really looking forward to what comes next...

Building the case against best practices

Michael W. McLaughlin of Deloitte Consulting has published an excellent article called "The Worst About Best Practices."  Like me, Mike is frustrated by the prevalence of best practices and the thinking they promote.  As he writes:

The problem with best practices is this: That approach lulls people into thinking that a best practice really exists that can be successfully transplanted.

I agree.  TAIB readers will recall that I selected "the impending death of best practices" as one of the Top 5 issues facing associations in 2005.  Great organizations do not create value for members, customers and stakeholders by copying the work of others.  They understand that in today's marketplace, creativity and originality are the primary drivers of value.  When association leaders try to replicate the experience of others because it seems expedient or efficient to do so, they surrender the opportunity to dazzle their members and give ground to for-profit and non-profit enterprises willing to embrace the challenge of innovation.  In this sense, then, whether and how our organizations use "best practices" is truly a question of leadership judgment, and one that association executives and volunteers cannot afford to get wrong.  To them, I offer the following advice:  let's dump best practices and focus on building better practice in our organizations. 

UPDATE:  I have added a new poll on best practices.  Please cast your vote.

New podcast on Associations Unorthodox

Just a quick note to let everyone know that there is a new podcast posted to Associations Unorthodox, the first podcast I've done in a month.  I'll be podcasting again later in the week.  Please check it out!

A bit morbid but fun...

Jsd_strategic_planning_tombstone_1

Thanks to my friend David Gammel over at High Context for connecting me to the Original Tombstone Generator site where you can, well, generate your own tombstone for whatever particular purpose you have in mind.  David sent me a "strategic planning is dead" version he created which I used in a presentation over the weekend. (Thanks David, it is really great!)  I decided to create another one myself, which I have posted above. 

I know it's a bit morbid, but we can still have a little fun with it, right?

Online article about podcasting for associations

This month's online edition of ASAE's Association Management magazine includes an article on podcasting in which I am extensively quoted.  As the association community's podcasting pioneer--a new completely immodest, self-referential superlative that I just created (whadda ya think?)--I'm very proud to have been included in the article.  I'm grateful to Jesse Alter, who was with AM at the time, for the fine job he did with this piece.  I hope you'll check it out!

A new blog...

In my continuing foray into the world of social media, I am pleased to announce that my friend and colleague, Jamie Notter, and I have launched The Association Renewal Blog.  Jamie and I have created a joint venture called Association Renewal LLC, a consultancy through which we will collaborate to deliver next generation leadership to associations today.  This blog is one mechanism we will use to engage our community in a fresh conversation about how we can do just that.

We hope you will read and subscribe to our new blog.  We promise it will be provocative and well worth your attention.  Check out today's posting on our recent article in Executive Update magazine. Thanks!

UPDATE:  Jamie has also launched his new blog, Get Me Jamie Notter at www.getmejamienotter.com.  Check it out!

Legal Stuff

FYI